Unlikely Story | The Rev. Dr. Anna S. Pearson, Rector

04.9.21 | Celebration, Community, Pulpit Posts, Uncategorized, World

“You shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you odd.” — attrib. Flannery O’Connor

These words are attributed to Southern Gothic writer Flannery O’Connor. No one seems to be able to find the exact citation for this quote, but even if she didn’t actually say or write it, the words sound like hers. O’Connor was a storyteller who ripped away the sentiment that can find its way into faith. A devout Christian, she insisted that God’s grace was most persistent in the least likely of places (and people). Her work is full of individuals who become conduits of that grace, even if they remain ignorant, or actively resist it. “All my stories,” she wrote, “are about the action of grace on a character who is not very willing to support it.”

The Easter story makes no conventional sense. Even before the miracle of the resurrection, we see the central character refusing to save himself when all around him are scrambling to do so. We see him replacing vengeance with forgiveness. Later he walks among his friends after what everyone thought was the unqualified final chapter in the tale. And then, the story gains traction through witnesses with a very spotty track record. All proof texts for the action of grace working through many people and multiple systems “not very willing to support it!” A writer’s room would probably reject this unbelievable narrative arc. An editor would have some suggestions about how to pull its preposterous claims into a more cohesive whole.

It is strange, this story about assumptions turned inside out; about the world shattered and remade with the only enduring and sustainable emotional currency possible. The truth offered in the Passion and Resurrection is completely out of step with what we think we know. By extension, we become odd when we claim this truth as our own. This happened to the earliest followers of Jesus, and it happens to us today. Forming our lives around God’s mysterious work through the Holy Spirit pulls us into seeing everything differently. Following in the steps of Christ leads us to a life of freedom beyond convention, of abundance in all circumstances

Too unlikely? I close with more words from Flannery O’Connor: “If you feel you can’t believe, you must at least do this: keep an open mind. Keep it open toward faith, keep wanting it, keep asking for it, and leave the rest to God.”

Easter blessings,

Rev. Dr. Anna S. Pearson

Rev. Dr. Anna S. Pearson


Stay current on activity at the Soup Kitchen, guest stories, thoughts from Clergy, news and events.

Subscribe to receive the latest news, events, volunteer opportunities, and more — right to your inbox.

Church of the Holy Apostles

We are an open, inclusive Christian Church celebrating in the Episcopal tradition.

Sunday Service is held 11AM (on site and via livestream). Weekday services are held on Zoom.


For Newcomers

Learn about our faith community and explore ways to connect with our work and worship.


Reflections on Holy Scripture from our Clergy.


Founded in 1844, with a focus on social activism and the desire for social justice.

Clergy, Staff & Vestry

The Vestry is the governing body of the Church of the Holy Apostles.


Music commands a strong presence at the Church of the Holy Apostles.

Space Rental

Host your next meeting or event in our landmark building.

Soup Kitchen & Pantry

Nourishing hungry New Yorkers since 1982 in an atmosphere of respect and hospitality.

Daily meal service

Serving a free, nutritious meal every weekday from 10:30 am to 12:30 pm.

Meal outreach

Distributing bagged breakfasts and lunches throughout Chelsea and Hell’s Kitchen.

About the soup kitchen

Learn more about our mission, our history, our performance, who we are, and what we do.

Pantry Program

Providing fresh and nutritious groceries to food-insecure New Yorkers.

Sunday Supper

Bridging generations and building community over a monthly family style meal.

Social Support

Meeting basic needs, stabilizing lives, and supporting individuals and families to achieve their goals.


Addressing the needs of the whole person through basic needs, counseling, and referrals.


Offering learning and skill-building opportunities.

Community Partnership

Partnering with others to expand the services offered to our guests.

Get Involved

Holy Apostles is a great place to channel your time, talents and generosity for good.


Make a difference in the lives of New Yorkers experiencing homelessness and hunger.


Join our efforts to serve others and provide for people who are vulnerable.


Your gift provides food, community, and hope to New Yorkers in need.

The Latest

Stay up-to-date on all happenings at Holy Apostles.

Food For The Soul

The official blog of Holy Apostles Soup Kitchen.

Voices of Our Community

Guest stories, poetry, and more.


See our calendar of events.

Church Pulpit Posts

Read weekly meditations written by our clergy.


Holy Apostles in the news.